Beyond Religion: How Economics Shaped the Arab Conquest of Sindh
In 711 CE, the armies of Muhammad ibn al-Qasim entered Sindh and history acquired two rival narratives.
In India’s right-wing historiography, the conquest became the opening act of a dark age, driven by the determination to spread Islam. Across the border, Pakistan embraced the same invasion from the opposite direction, presenting it as an opening chapter of its national story.
Both narratives place religion at the centre. History, however, is seldom confined to the meanings later generations assign to it.

'The Wealth Networks: How Roads, Rivers and Seas Shaped India', Akshay Chavan, Penguin India.
Look a level deeper, and another powerful force emerges: economics. Empires were driven by the desire to control lucrative supply chains and the strategic geography through which wealth flowed. The conquest of Sindh can therefore be understood as part of a larger historical pattern: geography created networks of wealth, and those networks attracted armies and shaped kingdoms.
To understand why Muhammad ibn al-Qasim invaded Sindh, it is necessary to understand what the control of Sindh meant. From the time of the Kushan Empire, between the first and fourth centuries CE, the central Asian Silk Route had developed into a network of immensely profitable corridors of exchange.
Silk passing through Persian territory was subjected to heavy duties that substantially increased its price. Merchants found a way around it by redirecting a part of the silk trade southwards towards the ports of Sindh, from where the commodity could be shipped westwards by sea. The merchants of Sauvira, as Sindh was then known, accumulated enormous wealth by serving this alternative route.
In the late seventh and early eighth centuries, with the Arab conquest of Persia, old routes were gradually redirected towards the needs of a new and expanding Umayyad empire. Beyond the empire’s eastern frontier lay Sindh, a land gateway from West Asia into the Indian subcontinent and a maritime junction connecting the Persian Gulf with the Arabian Sea and the Indian Ocean.
At the heart of this maritime network stood Debal, the port whose siege in 712 CE opens the following excerpt from Akshay Chavan's The Wealth Networks: How Roads, Rivers and Seas Shaped India, published by Penguin India.
§
The lances stood tall, their iron tips piercing the sky, each crowned with a fluttering tribal banner. Laying siege to the fortified walls of Debal – the main port of Sindh – was an army of 6,000 Syrian Arab soldiers. Their encampments stretched across the sands like a sea of steel and tents. Beyond Debal’s walls, rising defiantly, stood the spire of a grand temple, from whose mast a red banner fluttered in the coastal wind.
The order of the Arab General Muhammad ibn al-Qasim, just 17 years old, rang out across the ranks: raise the giant catapult. With a deep groan, the siege engine hurled its first massive boulder into the sky, and soon, the city was under a relentless storm of stone. One by one, the walls crumbled, then the temple spire, and then the gates of India’s western frontier burst open. It was 712 CE, and with the fall of Debal, the Arab conquest of Sindh had begun – a turning point that would alter the tides of Indian history.
The Arab empire maintained thriving trade links with South-East Asia and China, and Debal, the port city on the Sindh coast, was a critical port of call for ships sailing from the Persian Gulf into the Indian Ocean. The region was also intricately connected to the lucrative Silk Road trade via the Indus Valley and Kandahar, serving as a vital artery between India and Central Asia.
Though the official justification for the invasion of Sindh was to suppress ‘piracy’ off Debal’s coast, the campaign was actually part of a bold, two-pronged strategy to control the eastern trade routes.
As General Muhammad ibn al-Qasim advanced into Sindh, another Arab general, Qutayba ibn Muslim, was leading a simultaneous campaign into Bukhara, Samarkand and the broader Central Asian region. The overarching ambition was clear: to bring the entire Central Asian wealth network from the Oxus River to the Sindh coast under Umayyad control, thereby commanding the flow of the silk trade.
Following the conquest of Debal, the Arab armies advanced inland, defeating Raja Dahir (c. 679–712) of the Chach dynasty and capturing his capital, Aror known today as Rohri in Sindh. Aror was strategically vital, commanding the main crossing of the Indus River and sitting at the intersection of two crucial trade routes: one that ascended the Indus from coastal Sindh to Punjab, and another that descended from Central Asia via Kandahar, traversing the Thar Desert into the heart of India.
Centuries later, as the town of Aror declined and faded, the descendants of the once prosperous merchant families who had lived there migrated across India, carrying with them the memory of their lost city in their community’s name – the ‘Aroras’.
Muhammad ibn al-Qasim’s campaign brought back immense spoils of war. According to the ninth-century historian Al-Balādhurī, the conquest yielded 120 million dirhams in booty, a staggering fortune by any measure. With the conquest complete, Sindh was incorporated into the Umayyad caliphate, and Debal emerged as the key pivot for Arab ships sailing to China, transforming into one of the most important Arab ports in the Indian Ocean world.
Modern excavations at Banbhore, widely believed to be the site of Debal, reveal the contours of a prosperous trading town, with evidence of textile weaving, glass-making, ceramic glazing and metallurgy workshops. Debal retained its importance till as late as the thirteenth century, before the shifting course of the Indus River and the silting of the creek led to its demise.
Following the Arab conquest of Sindh, economic pressures played a significant role in driving conversions to Islam. At the time of the invasion, the majority of Sindh’s mercantile class was Buddhist. Just fifteen years before the Arab conquest, the Chinese traveller Hiuen Tsang journeyed through the upper Indus regions and recorded the presence of 460 monasteries and 26,000 monks across the greater Sindh region.
The Arab conquest disrupted the equilibrium of the Buddhist trade networks with central Asia, shifting power in favour of Arab merchants, who received preferential treatment under the new regime. The destruction of Buddhist monasteries, coupled with the confiscation of their wealth, further eroded the financial base of the Buddhist community.
Additionally, the imposition of higher customs duties on non-Muslim merchants as dhimmis created further economic strain. Over time, these combined pressures – loss of trade advantages, institutional destruction and fiscal discrimination – prompted many Buddhist traders and artisans to convert to Islam, seeking to retain their livelihoods within the new political and economic order.
In contrast, Sindh’s Hindu population, anchored in agrarian wealth and rural networks as warriors, farmers and administrators, was better positioned to withstand the economic and social pressures of the Arab conquest. Hinduism in Sindh was predominantly centred around Shaivite traditions.
In fact, the name of Debal, Sindh’s chief port, is believed to have been derived from the grand temple (deval) dedicated to Maheshwara Shiva that stood there. It was this temple’s towering spire that became the primary target of Muhammad ibn al-Qasim’s catapult during the siege in 712 CE.
While many urban temples were destroyed in the wake of the conquest, rural temples remained largely untouched, creating pockets of continuity for Hindu religious life. It was only gradually, over centuries, that Islam diffused into rural Sindh.
Akshay Chavan is an author who explores how economic, geographic and social forces shape the modern world. He currently heads Pratiti Foundation, working with diverse communities to build shared knowledge, skills and enduring livelihoods.
This article went live on October ninth, two thousand twenty six, at fifteen minutes past seven in the evening.The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.





