Privacy in the Age of Google

Privacy is a paradox. We demand it, yet constantly surrender it. We legislate for it, yet gossip away its essence at the dinner table. We feared gossip, now we fear Google. Privacy Right and Data Protection – Trust, Overreach and Erosion by Dr. S. Chakravarthy (Administrative Staff College of India (ASCI), 2024) – released by ASCI on November 17, 2024 – is a sharp reminder that erosion of privacy isn’t dramatic – it’s daily, silent, and often invited with a careless click. A must-read for anyone who thinks a password is enough.

The author steps into this paradox and attempts to decode its layers in the Indian context, while casting an occasional glance at the global horizon. The result is a timely, sharp, and at moments unsettling inquiry into what privacy means when trust is fragile, state power is expanding, and technology is omnipresent.

Setting the stage: India in transition

The book is anchored in India’s messy but fascinating data protection journey. From the landmark Puttaswamy judgment of 2017, which elevated privacy to a fundamental right, to the more recent Digital Personal Data Protection Act (2023), India has oscillated between constitutional guarantees and executive overreach.

Aadhaar, once sold as a tool of empowerment, has morphed into a symbol of both inclusion and intrusion. The book’s strength lies in situating these developments in a broader arc: how trust in institutions, corporations, and even fellow citizens is negotiated through the fragile lens of data.

The author does not write in the dry prose of policy manuals. Instead, he weaves legal, philosophical, and technological strands into a narrative that is accessible but not simplistic. For readers exhausted by jargon, this book feels like a breath of clarity.

The gossip factor: Privacy before privacy

What elevates the text beyond a simple commentary on data law is its recognition – explicit or implicit –that privacy has always been contested. Long before servers and surveillance cameras, societies leaked data through gossip. Whisper networks, reputational tales, and scandal-mongering were the primitive algorithms of social regulation. One’s marriage prospects, business opportunities, and even safety depended on how one was perceived in the village square.

Here lies the book’s deeper resonance: today’s debates on WhatsApp leaks, Pegasus spyware, or corporate profiling are not so alien. They are digital mutations of an older human tendency – to know, to tell, to warn, and to shame. Gossip, much to the consternation of moralists, was often the only firewall against abuse of power.

It deterred misconduct through the fear of public opinion, serving both as an informal policing mechanism and as a marketplace of reputations. The book invites us – sometimes directly, sometimes between the lines – to reflect on how this ancient “data breach” complicates our quest for perfect privacy.

Trust, overreach, and the inevitable erosion

The book’s subtitle is not ornamental; it defines its architecture.

• Trust is presented as both foundational and fragile. Can we trust governments not to misuse biometric databases? Can we trust corporations that profit from behavioural data? More fundamentally, can we trust each other when the boundary between private and public has blurred?
• Overreach is illustrated in examples where noble intentions curdle into coercion: welfare schemes that demand intrusive verification, law enforcement agencies that invoke “national security” to justify limitless surveillance, or platforms that manipulate users under the guise of convenience.
• Erosion captures the subtle daily compromises: when citizens click “I Agree” without reading, when journalists trade sources for scoops, or when political campaigns harvest micro-targeted data. Privacy does not collapse in a single blow; it erodes slowly, like a coastline battered by waves.

The prose here is persuasive, though occasionally repetitive. At times, the book risks stating the obvious–that surveillance threatens liberty, that data misuse is rampant. Yet repetition also mirrors the relentlessness of the problem: we need reminders because we forget too easily.

India at the centre, world at the margins

What distinguishes this book from the usual global-privacy discourse is its insistence on India’s centrality. While Europe debates the GDPR and the U.S. struggles with fragmented state laws, India experiments at scale – with biometric IDs, digital public infrastructure, and a billion users online. The author rightly notes that the stakes are higher here: a data breach in India is not just about consumer inconvenience; it can mean exclusion from rations, healthcare, or voting rights.

Global perspectives appear in passing – references to GDPR, the Cambridge Analytica scandal, or Chinese surveillance capitalism – but they remain background scenery. The focus is firmly on India, and rightly so. For a country still negotiating the balance between development and dignity, this conversation is existential.

Style and voice: Between academia and polemic

The book straddles an interesting line. It is researched enough to satisfy policy enthusiasts, yet conversational enough to attract general readers. The wit surfaces in sly phrases, the criticism in sharp turns of argument. Occasionally, the book leans too heavily on moral outrage; but in a domain where apathy is the norm, outrage feels refreshing.

What could be improved is a more robust engagement with counter-arguments. For example, surveillance also enables safety in high-crime contexts, and data sharing fuels innovation in health or disaster relief. These utilitarian angles are acknowledged but not explored deeply. A richer debate would have added texture.

Why it matters

Ultimately, the value of Privacy Right and Data Protection – Trust, Overreach and Erosion lies in its timing. At a moment when India is rolling out digital public infrastructure at breakneck speed, this book pauses to ask: at what cost? It reminds us that privacy is not just about secret passwords or encrypted chats; it is about the dignity of choice, the sanctity of intimacy, and the balance of power.

The wit ensures it doesn’t read like a government white paper; the philosophy ensures it isn’t reduced to mere policy talk. By embedding India’s legal milestones within a human narrative – and by gesturing toward the timeless shadow of gossip—the book becomes more than analysis. It becomes reflection.

This is not a perfect book, but it is a necessary one. Its imperfections – occasional repetition, partial neglect of counterpoints – are outweighed by its urgency and clarity. For policymakers, it is a cautionary tale. For academics, it is a resource. For ordinary readers, it is a wake-up call.

And for those of us who still believe gossip is society’s primitive data regulator, the book is a reminder that the challenge of privacy has never been new – only the tools have changed.

D. Samarender Reddy is the director of 7qube.com.

The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.