Elon Musk Takes on Ambani, PM Modi In 'Real Boss of India' Tweets
The Wire Staff
Real journalism holds power accountable
Since 2015, The Wire has done just that.
But we can continue only with your support.
New Delhi: Upset over how much time it is taking to clear Starlink's launch in India, SpaceX CEO Elon Musk took on the Modi government and conglomerate Ambani on X directly on the night of October 9. "Dear Prime Minister Ambani," he wrote, "Naturally, you would prefer to maintain your monopolistic exploitation of the great people of India, but would you nonetheless consider allowing Starlink to compete?"
Musk's Starlink is one of three companies hopeful of entering the satellite-internet sector in India, the others being Jio, owned by Mukesh Ambani-controlled Reliance, and Bharti-backed OneWeb.
Musk recently accused unnamed "certain oligarchs" of trying to block Starlink's entry into India, and on Friday named Ambani, owner of Jio. Jio is Starlink's soon-to-be-competitor in the sector – provided all goes well for both contenders in the race for permissions.
While Prime Minister Narendra Modi did not respond to Musk's jibes, nor did the Ambani group, Union Communications Minister Jyotiraditya Scindia said on Friday (October 9) that "India does not allow a monopoly in any sector" soon after Musk's post.
In an interview with the Hindu, Scindia referred to India's technology policy as "agnostic" and assured that "choice" would be offered to every Indian.
Scindia said that the government was working out the "revenue charges" system for all three operators keen to enter India's satellite communication sector. It also said it is conducting an unspecified security assessment of the three licence holders.
“Once the revenue charges system is finalised – once each one of these parties, party A, B and C, all three individually, based on their achievement of milestones about security concerns and prerequisites, have fulfilled the requirements – then obviously they can start operations,” Scindia said.
The minister did not directly respond to why security clearances were taking so long at the Department of Telecommunication (DoT). Instead, he told the publication that speeding up the process would invite the charge of being "in such a hurry".
The Union government said in a statement issued on Thursday (October 8) that all applicants to the newly opening up satellite internet sector were "broadly at the same regulatory stage".
The government did not give a clear timeline in the statement, saying only that "as and when" the security checks were done, each entity would individually "proceed to the next step". That would be the stage of seeking assignment of spectrum, the statement said.
In addition to security, spectrum assignment, costs and sharing have historically been a tricky phase in the privatisation of Indian airspace, rife with delays, often due to high competition over the limited resource. Since 2024, Scindia's ministry has settled on administratively assigning spectrum – though the cost schedule is yet to be fully worked out. Jio did not favour the allocation route, preferring spectrum auctions instead.
While traditional mobile networks rely on land-based cell towers, Starlink relies on a network of thousands of satellites orbiting Earth. Rivals Jio and Airtel have partnerships that allow them to compete.
As one of three applicants-in-waiting, Musk appears to have lost his patience (Starlink has been hopeful of entering the Indian market since 2022) and decided to embarrass the prime minister as well as his rival in the race. Modi has on numerous occassions faced accusations of favouring conglomerates, especially Adani and Ambani.
Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi had picked up on this thread on Thursday:
The Wire had previously reported that the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)-led Union government had directed state governments that have entered into agreements with Musk-owned Starlink to stop discussions and projects involving the satellite internet company until it secures the required licence to operate in India.
Musk has vigourously been promoting Starlink on his X account, saying "Internet connectivity enables education & prosperity" in a post right before the one about "Prime Minister Ambani".
This article went live on October tenth, two thousand twenty six, at twenty-seven minutes past twelve at noon.The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.
