Add The Wire As Your Trusted Source
View in Desktop Mode
HomePoliticsEconomyWorldSecurityLawScienceSocietyCultureEnvironmentEditors-PickVideo
Advertisement

Accused of Misconduct, Teaching Ethics: Why Delhi Police’s 'Guidelines for Journalists' Are Illegal and Dangerous

In a democracy, law enforcement is accountable to the public through the press, not the other way around. Police force, even in the national capital, is a law enforcement agency and has no statutory mandate to issue codes of conduct, operational rules, or press guidelines to journalists.
The Wire Analysis
Oct 06 2026
  • whatsapp
  • fb
  • twitter
In a democracy, law enforcement is accountable to the public through the press, not the other way around. Police force, even in the national capital, is a law enforcement agency and has no statutory mandate to issue codes of conduct, operational rules, or press guidelines to journalists.
A student activist clings to a Delhi Police bus to stop it from moving away with detained protesters, while security personnel intervene during a demonstration demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar over alleged electoral roll irregularities, near Jantar Mantar, in New Delhi, Friday, Oct. 2, 2026. Photo: PTI
Advertisement

The X update posted by the Delhi Police sermonising journalists on ‘#EthicsofJournalism’, while illustrating a reporter sticking a microphone into an officer's face, is problematic on multiple fronts. This is not a harmless ‘safety advisory’ but issued after women journalists alleged that Delhi Police personnel groped and assaulted them while they covered a Jantar Mantar protest, it is an attempt to reverse accountability for its own misconduct by prescribing the conduct of the complainants and their profession. 

Advertisement

The post is framed by the police as “guidelines” and “advised,” but it carries an implicit threat to anyhow control the narrative rather than address the substance. However, public reaction on social media such as mock reverse “guidelines for police,” and accusations of rewarding misconduct shows that the move has already backfired. Here is all that is wrong with the X update issued by Delhi Police.


Delhi Police cannot invent a press-censorship regime by an X update

In a democracy, law enforcement is accountable to the public through the press, not the other way around. Police, even in the national capital, is a law enforcement body and has no statutory mandate to issue codes of conduct, operational rules, or press guidelines to journalists. Article 19(1)(a) protects freedom of speech and expression, which includes the freedom of the press. There is no general legal requirement that a person must hold PIB accreditation, or be employed by a recognised newsroom, to report, record, observe, livestream, photograph or publish images and information from a public protest. 

In a system where Delhi Police operates directly under the union government, this kind of messaging from the central force carries extra weight as an assertion of unaccountable authority from the Modi regime. This is an attempt to weaponise a police order into a disciplinary platform for a constitutionally protected watchdog profession of journalism. It is meant to weaken democratic scrutiny precisely when scrutiny is most necessary in these times – during public demonstrations, arrests, crowd control and state’s use of force. Pushing reporters away from such active scenes severely limits their ability to document police conduct, detainments or use of excessive force on peaceful citizens.

Advertisement

This is victim-blaming and gaslighting by Delhi Police

The immediate public issue was allegations that women journalists were groped and assaulted by senior police personnel; Delhi Police said the complaints had been sent to its Crime branch. Rather than first focusing on survivor safety, evidence preservation, independent investigation and disciplinary accountability, the force launched an ethics lecture aimed at journalists. Using exaggerated AI-created graphic to present the police as calm subjects under siege by invasive reporters creates a biased narrative that shields the institution from accountability.

AI-generated graphics used by the Delhi Police to advise on 'ethical' conduct of journalists.

Posting graphics that depict journalists as aggressive harassers (the 'red cross' image) and lecturing them on ethics is an attempt to shift public attention from the alleged misconduct of senior police officers to the supposed professionalism of those who reported it. It implies that journalists’ positioning, identification or proximity may explain or mitigate police misconduct. Nothing about inadequate identification, proximity to a protest, or an alleged operational inconvenience can excuse sexual harassment, assault, unlawful restraint or interference with reporting.

It contravenes the constitutional significance of news-gathering

Reporting is not merely the final act of publication. If the state can push cameras, reporters and witnesses out of sight whenever force is used, the formal right to publish becomes hollow. The recognised link between press freedom and the protection of journalistic sources underscores that press freedom has procedural as well as publication-related dimensions. Requiring journalists to make themselves visually distinct from protesters cannot become a condition for being allowed to report. Allowing the state to dictate how it is observed fundamentally undermines independent reporting that speaks truth to power. 

The hashtag makes it worse

“Ethics of journalism” is not Delhi Police’s remit, or the remit of the Union home ministry which controls the force. Journalism’s professional ethics are debated within newsrooms, press bodies, academia and the public sphere. Police should enforce law fairly, facilitate lawful reporting, and be accountable for their own conduct. They better not moralise at the press after serious allegations of sexual misconduct against their senior personnel.

It deliberately conflates identification with permission

Carrying an ID may help operational coordination in a genuinely dangerous setting. But requiring specified ‘valid’ institutional or state accreditation as the badge of legitimacy risks excluding freelancers, stringers, documentary makers, student reporters, citizen journalists and independent digital reporters. Constitutional press freedom belongs to citizens, not only to credentialed media organisations. Even credentialed media organisations have numerous journalists without PIB accreditation.

The proposed limits are dangerously vague

“Do not obstruct,” “reasonable and safe distance,” and “clearly distinguish” are not defined by statute, measurable standards or an accountable procedure. In a protest or a police dispersal, such elastic language can be invoked after the fact to order reporters away from the very event they are documenting. It creates a discretionary threshold, where normal, persistent field reporting or questioning can be arbitrarily labelled criminal obstruction by the police. Unilaterally defining where journalists can stand without clear statutory authorisation creates arbitrary barriers around state action, subverting constitutional transparency and public oversight. It uses the pretext of scene-safety directions to impose blanket restrictions on coverage.

Also read: Can the Delhi Police Do Better Than This?

It lacks an SOP for police conduct

There is no stated commitment in this X update that police will not seize devices, delete footage, demand source material, threaten reporters or use accreditation status as a pretext to exclude them from reportage. It also doesn’t specify an operational protocol for officers. It has no mention of a press liaison officer, rapid grievance channel, direction for preservation of body-camera, supervisory review by an independent body, or procedure for documenting and justifying any exclusion of media.

Are Modi and Shah complicit in this?

Delhi Police is controlled by the Ministry of Home Affairs’ UT Division expressly handles Delhi Police, and the Delhi Police Commissioner is appointed by and answers to the Union government. Therefore, Amit Shah, as Union home minister, is the directly responsible political superior while Modi should intervene at the level of ministerial accountability. 

Shah’s first duty in this case is to order a credible, prompt and demonstrably independent investigation of the harassment allegations, preservation of CCTV/body-camera footage and deployment records, and action against any officer found responsible. And Modi has to ensure that law enforcement agencies operate within constitutional boundaries and remains accountable to public scrutiny. Else the duo would be seen as the hand behind this ham-handed attempt to impose censorship at a time when Modi is struggling politically and publicly under widely reported street protests.

This article went live on October sixth, two thousand twenty six, at twelve minutes past nine in the morning.

The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.

Advertisement
Make a contribution to Independent Journalism
Advertisement
View in Desktop Mode