Can the Delhi Police Do Better Than This?
Rohit Kumar
Real journalism holds power accountable
Since 2015, The Wire has done just that.
But we can continue only with your support.
The sheer scale and brutality of the state’s deployment against peacefully protesting citizens in central Delhi on October 2, 3 and 4 has left many of us stunned.
Although we can perhaps take some cold comfort from the fact that the violence this time did not involve tear gas, pellet guns and electrified batons as it did on July 20 earlier this year, the scenes of police aggression that emerged over the Gandhi Jayanti weekend were nonetheless deeply disturbing.
Especially distressing was the manner in which AISA president Neha Bora was whisked away in a private vehicle, accompanied only by male cops, as was the Parliament Street Police Station’s refusal to lodge an FIR against an officer accused of groping a woman journalist. Protesters, angry at these dangerously elevated levels of impunity, and viewing the police as Amit Shah’s personal instruments of repression more and more, have added a new chant to their repertoire:
“Delhi police vardi utaaro/ RSS ki knicker daalo”
As with any organisation, the character of a police force is shaped to a considerable extent by the character and priorities of its leadership. While there are always honourable exceptions to the rules, by and large, ‘the speed of the leader is the speed of the gang” and the culture of an organisation invariably reflect the values that its leaders model, reward and tolerate. In the case of the Delhi Police, too, those values are shaped by its leadership and, ultimately, by the Ministry of Home Affairs to which it reports.
But it wasn’t always like this.
Like many others who have lived in Delhi for a long time, I have seen different and better versions of the Delhi Police.
In the late 1990s and early 2000s, I worked with the police as a ‘communication and interpersonal-skills facilitator’, conducting training focused on communication, human relations and the way police personnel interact with citizens and with one another.
The bulk of this work was with Probationary Sub-Inspectors (PSIs) at the Police Training College at Jharoda Kalan, near Najafgarh, on the outskirts of Delhi. Probationary Sub-Inspectors are newly recruited police officers undergoing their initial training and field experience before being confirmed in the rank. They are trained in policing, law, investigation, discipline and public interaction, while their performance and conduct are assessed during probation.
A few years after her stint as Inspector General of Prisons at Tihar Jail, Kiran Bedi was made Joint Commissioner of Police (Training), and having seen our small volunteers team’s work with the inmates of Tihar Jail, felt we could help the PSIs be more humane and empathetic in their interaction and dealings with the public.
I will never forget my first interaction with the PSIs at the Police Training College in Jharoda Kalan, on a muggy August afternoon in 1999.
We had been expecting a small class of perhaps 25 to 50 trainees. Instead, we were led out onto an open field, where 1,200 probationary Sub-Inspectors sat on the grass in neat rows. None of us had ever worked with a gathering remotely this large.
We had to think on our feet. Fortunately, an idea occurred in the nick of time!
We asked the aspiring police officers to take out their pens and notebooks, and said: “Think of a time in your life when you genuinely and selflessly helped someone. Write down what happened – and, more importantly, how it made you feel.”
What happened next was unexpected and moving.
One by one, several PSIs came up to the microphone and shared deeply personal stories of moments when they had helped someone. A hush descended over the field. Some spoke with difficulty, a few broke down as they revisited memories they had carried with them for years. One spoke of saving a young accident victim’s life, another spoke of helping an elderly widow who was being harassed by her daughter-in-law. Yet another recalled an incident when he had gone out of his way to help a young Muslim family in trouble and the gratitude that he had received in return.
The common denominator in all these stories was the feeling of peace and joy they experienced after helping fellow human beings in need, thus underscoring the importance and rewards of empathy.
It was an unforgettable afternoon – and the beginning of many training sessions.
Pages of the booklet 'Memories – Jab Maine Haath Badhaya ('When I Reached Out to Help')'. Photo courtesy: Rohit Kumar.
The Joint Commissioner who was present that day, collected these stories and compiled them in a booklet called, Memories – Jab Maine Haath Badhaya ('When I Reached Out to Help') which subsequently became an official part of the Police Training College’s curriculum, alongside material on subjects such as lodging FIRs, crowd control and ballistics!
There was something wonderful about that juxtaposition: besides teaching young police officers how to control a crowd, investigate a crime and handle a weapon, they were also being asked to remember what it felt like to simply help another human being.
But the times have changed over the past quarter of a century. The good news, though, is that they have not changed once and for all.
Hannah Arendt’s essay on the “banality of evil” offers a chilling insight into what can happen inside hierarchical institutions. Evil does not always require monsters. Sometimes it requires only ordinary people to stop thinking, stop questioning and convince themselves that obedience is a sufficient defence: “I was only following orders.”
But there is another, more hopeful truth. There are always people who pause and question. The history of every institution contains such exceptions: people who understand that following orders may be their duty, but following their conscience is their responsibility.
I find it hard to believe that the sight of the young marching for something as basic as the right to vote in a democracy, and as fundamental as women’s safety has not tugged at the hearts of the men and women in uniform, especially of those who have not bought into the RSS’s worldview and who still have a functioning conscience.
And while the Delhi Police may have sunk to one of its lowest nadirs, tides turn. And when they rise, they lift all boats – including the one carrying those entrusted with keeping the law.
Rohit Kumar is an educator and can be reached at letsempathize@gmail.com.
This article went live on October fifth, two thousand twenty six, at fifty-four minutes past three in the afternoon.The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.
