Add The Wire As Your Trusted Source
For the best experience, open
https://m.thewire.in
on your mobile browser.
AdvertisementAdvertisement

Converts to Islam Cease to Possess Quota Benefits Promised to Hindu 'Backward' Communities: Supreme Court

'The social backwardness that forms the basis of a person's pre-conversion status cannot, by itself, constitute the legal foundation for conferring membership of a different notified backward class community after conversion,' the bench noted, upholding Madras high court ruling.
'The social backwardness that forms the basis of a person's pre-conversion status cannot, by itself, constitute the legal foundation for conferring membership of a different notified backward class community after conversion,' the bench noted, upholding Madras high court ruling.
converts to islam cease to possess quota benefits promised to hindu  backward  communities  supreme court
A view of the Supreme Court of India, in New Delhi. Photo: PTI /Karma Bhutia.
Advertisement

New Delhi: The Supreme Court, on Thursday (October 15), upheld a Madras high court ruling that said a person who converts to Islam cannot claim Backward Class reservation based on their caste or community status before conversion.

A bench of Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar dismissed the Tamil Nadu government's petition challenging the high court's judgement, which had resulted in the striking down of a 2024 government order that allowed certain individuals to be viewed as members of the state's notified list of Backward Class (Muslim) communities after converting to Islam.

In its judgement today, the Supreme Court held that conversion could not, by itself, make a person a member of any of the seven Muslim sects notified as backward classes under Tamil Nadu government's Backwards Classes, Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Reservation of Seats in Educational Institutions and of Appointments or Posts in the Services under the State) Act, 1993.

Pre-conversion social status not a basis

The court ruled that a person moving to a non-Hindu social order cannot claim affirmative action under article 16(4) of the constitution, despite the social backwardness associated with their pre-conversion status, reported Live Law.

"Such conversion severs the legal foundation of an entitlement conditioned upon membership of the Hindu social order," the court held.

Advertisement

It added that historical social, economic or political disadvantages in one social order cannot warrant similar classification upon conversion, observing that the seven notified Muslim communities under the state's law were not theological denominations comparable to Sunni or Shia communities in Islam.

"The social backwardness that forms the basis of a person's pre-conversion status cannot, by itself, constitute the legal foundation for conferring membership of a different notified backward class community after conversion," the bench noted, per Live Law.

Advertisement

Eligibility upon reconversion can be reassessed

Addressing the constitutional framework governing Scheduled Caste status, the court said persons professing religions other than Hinduism, Sikhism or Buddhism cannot be treated as members of a Scheduled Caste under the Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order.

"Upon conversion to a religion not specified therein, such person ceases to possess Scheduled Caste status and cannot claim affirmative action or benefits under Article 16(4) that are dependent on membership of a Scheduled Caste," the court observed.

Advertisement

The bench ruled that after reconversion to Hinduism, however, the individual's eligibility for affirmative action can reassessed through an independent, fact-specific evaluation of whether the "original caste or social identity has genuinely revived" upon reconversion and whether the person meets the applicable legal requirements.

Advertisement

The court also referred to previous judicial decisions, including Chinthada Anand v. State of Andhra Pradesh, wherein a person lost their Scheduled Caste status upon conversion to Islam or Christianity.

The petition

The present proceedings emerge from a petition filed by Sameer Ahamed in 2015, when he converted from Hinduism to Islam. According to the Live Law report, a gazette notification concerning his conversion was issued in 2016 and he subsequently married as per Islamic rites and customs and had two children.

Ahamed applied for a community certificate identifying him as belonging to the Muslim Lebbai community, one of the seven notified Backward (Muslim) Class communities in Tamil Nadu, along with Ansar, Dekkani Muslims, Dubekula, Mapilla, Sheik and Syed communities.

His application was rejected by the tehsildar, following which Ahmad approached the Madras high court, invoking a government order issued on March 9, 2024, by the Tamil Nadu Backward Classes, Most Backward Classes and Minorities Welfare Department.

However, the high court held that the order was unconstitutional and that it was inconsistent with judicial decisions ruling that conversion to Islam does not automatically confer membership of a particular Muslim community.

The Supreme Court's latest declaration backs this view, preventing people from marginalised communities to access the affirmative action they were entitled to upon conversion from Hinduism.

This article went live on October fifteenth, two thousand twenty six, at nine minutes past seven in the evening.

The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.

Advertisement
Advertisement
tlbr_img1 Series tlbr_img2 Columns tlbr_img3 Multimedia