Why TVK's Bypoll Wins Don't Exactly Spell Demise for the AIADMK
Kavitha Muralidharan
Real journalism holds power accountable
Since 2015, The Wire has done just that.
But we can continue only with your support.
The Tamilaga Vetri Kazhagam (TVK) has won both Madurantakam and Dharapuram, but the results offer a more complicated picture than the victories alone suggest. In Madurantakam, TVK’s vote share rose from 31.32% in the April assembly election to 39.96% in the October bypoll. In Dharapuram, it increased from 23.23% to 37.02%. The AIADMK’s share fell by 9.34 percentage points in Madurantakam and 15.48 points in Dharapuram, while the DMK’s share declined by just over one point and less than half a point respectively.
The results point to a shift in support from the AIADMK towards TVK, but not a wholesale transfer of the AIADMK’s electorate. Both TVK candidates were former AIADMK MLAs who resigned and joined Vijay’s party after winning their constituencies in April. Their victories suggest that at least some voters followed them across party lines. But TVK secured considerably less than the combined vote shares of the two parties in April, and the DMK retained much of its support. The question is how far the victories reflect Vijay’s appeal, the influence of the former MLAs, the intensity of the campaign or the advantages of campaigning as the ruling party.
In Madurantakam, K Maragatham Kumaravel won by 20,040 votes, polling 74,048 against the DMK’s I Paranthaman, who received 54,008 votes. The AIADMK’s Kanitha Sampath finished third with 47,450 votes. In Dharapuram, P Sathyabama defeated DMK candidate S Suganya by 9,471 votes, securing 66,841 votes against Suganya’s 57,370. AIADMK candidate K Bhanumathi received 45,280 votes. TVK’s margin in Dharapuram was considerably narrower than in Madurantakam, despite the larger increase in its vote share there. The party has won both seats, but the results are not identical in what they reveal about the local contests.
'Vijay down to the ground'
Political analyst Raja Gambeeran says the by-election brought Vijay down to the ground. “We have only seen men take their first steps on foot and then move on to buses, trains or flights. In Vijay’s case, he began his political journey in a flight, and this by-election has brought him down to earth. We saw him walking the streets, drinking tea, plucking drumsticks and driving a tractor. The fear of losing the by-election has made him do all this.”
In this image posted on Oct. 9, 2026, Tamil Nadu Chief Minister and TVK chief C Joseph Vijay, centre, along with Arunraj KG, left, and other party leaders during a meeting following the Secular Social Justice Victory Alliance's win in the Dharapuram and Maduranthakam assembly by-elections, in Chennai. Photo: @arunraajkg/X via PTI.
The campaign coincided with TVK’s position as the ruling party, giving it the visibility and organisational advantages that come with government. The opposition alleged that money was distributed to voters and that official machinery was used to benefit TVK. These allegations were denied by the ruling party and should not be treated as established facts. Nevertheless, they formed part of the political contest and complicate any attempt to attribute the results exclusively to Vijay’s personal appeal.
The results have also intensified the debate over TVK’s claim to represent a thooya sakthi, or pure political force. In his post-election message, Vijay said the party had won without distributing money or gifts to voters and without resorting to what he called the “Thirumangalam” or “Erode East” formulas. He described the victories as a result of public affection and democratic faith, and as a rebuke to personal attacks and remarks targeting women.
Former Tamil Nadu chief minister and Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK) President M K Stalin during an election campaign for party candidate Paranthamana ahead of the Maduranthagam by-poll election, in Chengalpattu district, Saturday, Oct. 3, 2026. Photo: PTI.
DMK president M.K. Stalin offered a sharply different reading. He called the result an “interim victory for betrayal” and said the decline of politics built on false images had begun. He alleged that TVK had used money, gifts, intimidation and government and police machinery to secure victory. He also criticised Vijay’s campaign stops and gestures, including drinking tea and driving a tractor, presenting them as political theatre rather than evidence of public service.
AIADMK general secretary Edappadi K Palaniswami similarly accused TVK of using money power and official authority. He described the result as a temporary setback and maintained that the AIADMK remained an enduring political force. He also alleged that AIADMK candidates and cadres had been intimidated through false cases.
For the AIADMK, the decline in vote share is significant. It fell from 34.95% to 25.61% in Madurantakam and from 40.56% to 25.08% in Dharapuram. The party had won both constituencies in April but finished third this time. Its immediate challenge is to explain why substantial portions of its previous support did not remain with it after two of its legislators crossed over to TVK. Palaniswami has sought to frame the result as temporary and insist that the AIADMK’s political base remains intact. But the numbers show that the party has lost ground in these two constituencies and as observers point out might encourage more legislators from the AIADMK to crossover.
What of the PMK?
The speculation that the Pattali Makkal Katchi (PMK) could join the TVK-led alliance adds another layer of uncertainty. The PMK, which was part of the AIADMK-led alliance in the assembly election, remained neutral during the bypolls. Its potential entry, however, could unsettle TVK’s existing relationships. VCK leader Thol Thirumavalavan has reiterated that his party would not be part of an alliance that includes the PMK.
The CPI and CPI(M) are already in an unusual position within the TVK government’s support structure. Both parties extended outside support to Vijay’s government but chose not to join its formal electoral alliance. They also decided to contest the two bypolls independently, with the CPI(M) fielding P Suganthi in Madurantakam and the CPI nominating P Lakshmanan in Dharapuram. They maintained that contesting against TVK candidates would not affect their outside support for the government.
The electoral outcome, however, was sobering. Suganthi polled 1,986 votes in Madurantakam, while Lakshmanan secured 1,157 in Dharapuram — fewer than the 3,000 votes that Left sources reportedly hoped to secure in each constituency. The results exposed the difficulty of translating the Left’s ideological presence and legislative role into an independent electoral base. The Left leaders have defended the exercise as an opportunity to take their politics to voters, but the numbers underline the distance between their role in political debates and their ability to mobilise votes independently.
This experience complicates the speculation over the PMK’s entry into TVK. Vijay may see the PMK as a way to widen his social and electoral reach, but bringing it into the alliance could push the VCK out and create tensions with the Left. The CPI and CPI(M) have demonstrated that outside support for the government does not mean electoral alignment with it. If the PMK joins, they would have to decide whether their present arrangement remains tenable. For TVK, the challenge is not merely to add parties but to retain the support of those whose political commitments may conflict with a wider coalition. For the Left, the challenge is to preserve its independence without allowing that independence to become electorally marginal.
The two victories have taken TVK’s strength in the assembly to 109. Five seats remain vacant: Tiruchirappalli East, which Vijay vacated after retaining Perambur, and Perundurai, Ambasamudram, Viralimalai and Karur, where AIADMK legislators resigned and joined TVK. Even if TVK wins all five, its strength would rise to 114, below the 118 seats required for a majority in a fully constituted 234-member House. The effective majority threshold can differ while seats remain vacant, but the arithmetic underlines the importance of TVK retaining the support of its allies.
There is, however, a larger contradiction at the heart of TVK’s politics. Vijay entered public life promising a thooya sakthi, a pure political force that would break with the practices of established parties. Yet observers say the TVK has already abandoned that founding promise. It has embraced legislators elected on another party’s ticket who resigned to join the ruling party, faces allegations of cash distribution and misuse of official machinery, and is negotiating alliance arrangements that could force it to choose between partners with conflicting political commitments.
The bypolls have added two seats to TVK’s tally, but they have also brought this contradiction into focus.
This article went live on October tenth, two thousand twenty six, at twenty-three minutes past four in the afternoon.The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.
