Add The Wire As Your Trusted Source
For the best experience, open
https://m.thewire.in
on your mobile browser.
AdvertisementAdvertisement

Delhi SIR: Supreme Court Now Says Right to Vote 'Vital', 'Logical Discrepancy Interim Arrangement'

On the issue of 47 lakh people in ASDD list, the court asked ECI why they couldn’t be given an opportunity to fill enumeration forms or file Form 8.
On the issue of 47 lakh people in ASDD list, the court asked ECI why they couldn’t be given an opportunity to fill enumeration forms or file Form 8.
delhi sir  supreme court now says right to vote  vital    logical discrepancy interim arrangement
A view of the Supreme Court of India. Photo: PTI/Karma Bhutia.
Advertisement

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Wednesday (October 28) questioned the Election Commission of India why a voter who is already on the electoral roll should have to fill Form 6 to seek inclusion in the draft roll simply because the Election Commission of India (ECI) official could not reach them during special intensive revision (SIR).

It also said the right to vote was a “vital right” and a voter could not be deprived of it merely because they had failed to update their electoral details during the SIR.

Hearing the writ petition filed by Anjali Bharadwaj and Amrita Johri over the various issues in the SIR exercise in Delhi, a bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana pointed out that Form 6 is meant only for first-time voters, where the applicants have to declare that they have not voted before. 

The top court underscored that in Delhi, there would be various persons on whom enumeration forms could not be served as they changed their addresses, or have temporarily gone out of the city for work.

“Instead of burdening them to approach you, why don’t you reach out to them?” CJI Kant asked, as quoted by Supreme Court Observer. 

Advertisement

Senior advocate Prashant Bhushan, appearing for the petitioners, had submitted that 47 lakh persons from Delhi’s 1.45 crore voters had not returned their enumeration forms, and of them 43 lakh of these had been classified under ASDD (Absentee / Shifted / Duplicate / Deceased) list. He pointed out that many voters had not received their enumeration forms, because it carried their previous addresses, and the ECI required them to file Form 6 (for new voter) rather than Form 8 (to show change in address).

Also read: In Four Booths, One in Three Removals Wrong: Public Hearing in Trilokpuri Puts Delhi SIR Under Scrutiny

Advertisement

Bhushan also argued that 19.34 lakh cases in Delhi lay under a 'logical discrepancy' category, and that the ECI had not clearly explained why.

Justice Bagchi claimed that the top court had not ruled on the legality of the logical discrepancy list. He said its use had been permitted only as an interim arrangement in the West Bengal proceedings, while the Bihar SIR judgment had not examined the issue.

Advertisement

Advertisement

On the issue of 47 lakh people in ASDD list, the court asked ECI why they couldn’t be given an opportunity to fill enumeration forms or file Form 8.

Justice Baghchi, LiveLaw reported, asked senior advocate Dama Seshadri Naidu, representing the ECI: "You call upon the person to file Form 6, declaring my name was never in the list. It's an error.”

“SIR Form 6 should say my name is not included in the 2003 voters list. But if you take 2026 as cutoff, and someone has shifted, you have to permit them Form 8," he added.

The top court termed it a structural incongruity, and said it has to be addressed.

The CJI suggested that the ECI can, in a statement or circular, “clarify that Form 6 is required to be filled only by those who want to register as first time voters in NCT of Delhi.” 

The court also suggested that the deadline for filling of enumeration form or Form 8 should be extended as there are no elections scheduled in Delhi.

Meanwhile, Justice Bagchi noted that Form 6, Form 7, Form 8 are "cast in stone" and cannot be changed, though in the SIR process, the ECI has residual powers to add to them by seeking declarations. Justice Bagchi suggested that a declaration can be sought as to why they could not collect or respond to the enumeration form.

For our full coverage on the SIR and the issues it has brought to citizens, click here. 

This article went live on October twenty-eighth, two thousand twenty six, at four minutes past eight in the evening.

The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.

Advertisement
Advertisement
tlbr_img1 Series tlbr_img2 Columns tlbr_img3 Multimedia