Add The Wire As Your Trusted Source
For the best experience, open
https://m.thewire.in
on your mobile browser.
AdvertisementAdvertisement

'Gaslighting', 'Patriarchy', 'No Mention of Real Victims': Internet Unimpressed With Modi’s Latest 'Forgiving' Act 

'Adult women don’t need your moral policing,' most of the reactions seemed to say, while others pointed to the shame that should accompany any system that forces a teenager to seek forgiveness over criticising a PM.
'Adult women don’t need your moral policing,' most of the reactions seemed to say, while others pointed to the shame that should accompany any system that forces a teenager to seek forgiveness over criticising a PM.
 gaslighting    patriarchy    no mention of real victims   internet unimpressed with modi’s latest  forgiving  act 
Illustration: Modi and the tweets after his video was released on July 31.
Advertisement

New Delhi: At 11.06 pm on July 31, 11 days after security forces unleashed merciless lathicharge, fired pellet guns and tear gas at protesting youth in Jantar Mantar, prime minister Narendra Modi acknowledged the event for the first time. The protest was against his dispensation and has led to the resignation of this education minister Dharmendra Pradhan, yet if you thought that Modi had come ready with a midnight apology, you would be mistaken. Modi said that he was “shocked” at female protesters using expletives and said he wished to forgive such “misled children”.

In the year of 2026, a prime minister expressing selective shock at women's use of expletives – in a protest where men were unsparing in their language too – has not gone down particularly well.

"Adult women don’t need your moral policing," @MsAnjaliRB, a commentator on X pointed out. "They aren’t your daughters. Men abused you too, yet your boring asf lecture was reserved for women. Whenever women step outside your patriarchal, nationalist idea of how they should behave, you label it a “cultural crisis.”"

Cartoonist Sanitary Panels put it straight and noted that girls and women do not owe the prime minister civility:

"Clutching pearls and pretending you’re a victim while kids have DIED BY SUICIDE because of your fuck ups and then YOUR POLICE USED PELLET GUNS AND AK47s AND LATHIS ON PROTESTERS."

Advertisement

Hotmail founder Sabeer Bhatia asked exactly what the prime minister forgave protesters for:

The Prime Minister made a reel saying he “forgives” the students for their actions and mistakes.

Advertisement

Forgives them for what? For asking for their rights? For demanding fairness?

A true leader would apologize to the students for allowing the police to beat them-not expect an apology from them.

Advertisement

That is leadership. That is democracy.

Advertisement

Modi's decision to forgive comes as his legions of supporters have unleashed a phenomenal doxxing and harassment drive against women and minor girl protesters who criticised Modi. A day ago, the Noida police filed a case against a young woman for using “abusive language against Narendra Modi”. Pro-government mainstream media has also launched into a process of demonising her. The minor has uploaded a video saying that she is 15 years old and is sorry for the language she used.

"The whole nation should HANG ITS HEAD IN SHAME for TERRORISING a 15 year old MINOR child to issue an apology over camera to WHOLE NATION for something that GROWN-UP adults do DAILY in this country WITH IMPUNITY," X commentator @keshavbedi said.

AISA, which led the protests at Jantar Mantar alongside the Cockroach Janata Party, also echoed this sentiment.

In a statement, the party said:

"The real cultural shock for this country has been the indiscriminate and vehement usage of batons, pellets and even bullets against unarmed people protesting for their rights! It has been the shameful normalcy of trolling and doxxing dissenters and giving rape threats to women and gender minorities. All this done by the IT cell run with utmost precision by Amit Malviya.

"We hope the Prime Minister releases a video addressing this, saying, "I am taking accountability, and I am removing Home Minister Amit Shah."

The News Minute founder Dhanya Rajendran noted how CNNNews18 took down its video on the girl after Modi's missive, observing how the channel felt no compunction before unleashing vitriol over a person exercising their right.

Alt News founder, fact-checker Mohammad Zubair was quick to point out that Modi and his party set the gold standard for abuse either way.

Zubair's comment saying, "Sir, If you really want set an example, then please start unfollowing the abusers you've been following since 2014," is one of the most 'liked' of all reactions under Modi's original post.

He was echoed by user @iArpitSpeaks, who said, "Kisi bhi sabhya samaaj mein gaali shobha nahi deti- toh ye baat apne IT cell ko samjhado ek reel banakar (Abuses do not credit any civilised society – so explain this to your IT cell in a reel)."

Others pointed out that Modi is no stranger to himself using abusive language.

Several commenters posted a parody video which showed the language used by BJP leaders in public fora.

X user @meherness pointed to the acute double standards and said: "Indian RW in a nutshell: teri maa ka b*****, tune modiji ko gaali kaise diya saali r****"

Some called the targeted protester brave "unlike Narendra Modi."

One @NamraPatel__ put it simply: "Kids don't lie sir" and posted a video of the brutality of the police on July 20.

Comedians and writers Vir Das and Varun Grover also pitched in.

"Have a look at the comments section or dms of any girl in India. Then maybe we can lecture them about their own language," Das said.

Grover referred to Justice Joymalya Bagchi's line at the Supreme Court to say: "If exceptional conditions can justify pellet guns, why don’t they justify some cuss words?"

Another user, @ashish_nujs, pointed out:

"Amit Shah can use cuss words on floor of Parliament, Chief Justice of India can call people cockroaches and parasites from the bench. Police can abuse student protesters on camera with impunity. But kids swearing on the streets suddenly becomes Bharat sanskriti and sanskar issue"

Meanwhile, one of the Gen Z protesters who has been targeted by the BJP IT Cell has made a characteristically irreverent video berating the abusers for having a weak caption game and more.

This article went live on August first, two thousand twenty six, at fifty-one minutes past eleven in the morning.

The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.

Advertisement
Advertisement
tlbr_img1 Series tlbr_img2 Columns tlbr_img3 Multimedia