Add The Wire As Your Trusted Source
For the best experience, open
https://m.thewire.in
on your mobile browser.
AdvertisementAdvertisement

'Good for India': Piyush Goyal Speaks After US–India Friction Since Vance's Visa Fraud Conference

The minister did not account for the massive disparity in savings and the boost that immigrant workers in the US are able provide their families in India.
The minister did not account for the massive disparity in savings and the boost that immigrant workers in the US are able provide their families in India.
 good for india   piyush goyal speaks after us–india friction since vance s visa fraud conference
Union Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal with others during a business roundtable convened by the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM), on the sidelines of the G20 Trade Ministerial meeting, in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA. Photo: @PiyushGoyal/X via PTI Photo
Advertisement

New Delhi: Union Cabinet Minister Piyush Goyal has sought to give the United States' recent economic and diplomatic blow to H1-B visa-seekers and green card aspirants a self-reliance spin. Speaking at a 'Startup Awards' ceremony hosted by the Economic Times, he said, "I personally believe that not getting more H-1B visas is absolutely good for the Indian economy. It's good news for all of us."

Goyal, who just ended a whirlwind trip to the US meeting business leaders, also said Indians working domestically for American companies could be hired for a fifth or a sixth of what they are paid when they go to the US with a dual intent: work for a few years, then get on the green card track.

The United States has suspended the Permanent Labour Certification (PERM) programme for major technology companies, including Microsoft and Indian companies including Tata Consultancy Services, Infosys, Wipro and HCL Technologies.

"I heard Tata say that they will not be hit at all by this," Goyal said in response to a direct query on the impact of this decision by the US.

Goyal also said that he viewed the H1-B visas granted to skilled professionals as a brain drain. "I wonder what would have happened if all of them had been doing their businesses, their research, businesses in India," he said.

Advertisement

Also read: ‘Deeply Offensive’: India Invokes Colonial Past, Takes Exception to Vance’s ‘Indentured Servants’ Remark

He then referred to remote work as a real possibility, evidently for those unable to secure visas, saying he believed "only a few" really needed to physically be in the US.

Advertisement

Almost appearing to celebrate the under-payment of Indian workers, Goyal also suggested that American companies could hire Indians to work remotely "at maybe one-fifth or one-sixth" the cost of an Indian immigrant worker. The Indian workers could then "stay at home" with their families in India.

"And family life, for all of us, we know is very important. It's really what defines India," he said, proceeding to extoll India's "tradition" and "closely-knit" family systems.

Advertisement

Besides, he argued, "all" US companies want to set up shop or expand their presence in India.

Advertisement

"Every manufacturing company wants to be in India. Every insurance company wants to be in India. One of the largest investors from New York plans to double down their investments in the next three or four years from $50 billion to $100 billion," he said.

He said Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Pune, Gurugram, Noida and Mumbai would be magnets for these investments, particularly into GCCs or Global Capability Centres. Last year, when around 5 lakh skilled Indian professionals were said to be hit by the Trump tariffs followed by previous rounds of visa curbs, India had moved to shore up GCC presence.

But Goyal said he "never ever" discussed the visa issue with his US counterparts in the 7.5 years at the helm of the commerce and industry ministry.

“Immigration isn't an FTA [Free Trade Agreement] issue or directly related to trade,” he said, adding that countries had the right to regulate immigration. He distinguished immigration from the movement of people required to provide services across borders, which is relevant to trade.

According to Goyal, "not getting H-1B visas" would "probably" give the startup ecosystem "a greater thrust – we've only just begun".

Also read: US Freezes Green Card Route for Microsoft, Infosys, Tata; Vance Says 'Visa Fraud'

Towards the end of his talk, the minister referred to Flipkart's Group CEO, saying, "When Kalyan Krishnamurthy started Flipkart, I don't think he had budgeted or he had planned to be where he is today. He must have made future projections, but he didn't realise the scale of the opportunity [in India]."

Flipkart was founded by Sachin Bansal and Binny Bansal, while Krishnamurthy has been involved in various top management positions in the compny and in the Flipkart Group since its early years. Krishnamurthy is a global finance professional, with previous stints in Tiger Global and eBay Asia Pacific.

What is more, Walmart (a US retail giant) owns a majority (77%) stake in Flipkart, and remains a competitor in the Indian market to another US giant, Amazon. Put simply, Flipkart is a foreign-controlled company. Binny Bansal and Sachin Bansal have moved on to other ventures, while Krishnamurthy runs Flipkart as the Group CEO.

Referring to the competitors for the award function he was speaking at, Goyal said, "If I was not a minister, and if this would not be considered as insider trading, I think all I needed to do was check your [the day's] list of winners and invest in them, and I'm sorted for the rest of my life."

This article went live on October tenth, two thousand twenty six, at forty-two minutes past one in the afternoon.

The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.

Advertisement
Advertisement
tlbr_img1 Series tlbr_img2 Columns tlbr_img3 Multimedia