Add The Wire As Your Trusted Source
For the best experience, open
https://m.thewire.in
on your mobile browser.
AdvertisementAdvertisement

Delhi Does Not Lack Laws on Construction and Maintenance, It Lacks the Will to Implement Them

The real measure of a smart city is not how quickly it can detect and report a disaster but how effectively it can prevent one.
The real measure of a smart city is not how quickly it can detect and report a disaster but how effectively it can prevent one.
delhi does not lack laws on construction and maintenance  it lacks the will to implement them
Workers carry out demolition work on the roof of a building adjacent to the paying guest accommodation that recently collapsed, at Satya Niketan, in New Delhi. Photo: PTI
Advertisement

On June 3, a fire broke out in a five-storey building in Malviya Nagar. On paper, it was a bed and breakfast licensed for six rooms. It had no no-objection certificate from the Fire Service, no second staircase, no functioning fire-fighting system, and windows sealed shut. When smoke filled the narrow corridors, there was nowhere to go. Seventeen fire tenders later, 21 people were dead of which nine African nationals, two from Turkmenistan, ten Indians, most in Delhi for cheap medical treatment, study or work. Most died of asphyxiation, not burns.

About three months later, on September 6, a 50-year-old building in Satya Niketan, the warren of eating joints and paying-guest accommodations behind Delhi University's South Campus, collapsed. Basement repair work was underway and days of rain had pooled water into foundations weakened by decades of illegal additions. A worker had warned that a wall could give way. And it did, in seconds. Seven people died, five of them students. National Disaster Response Force teams worked through the night, wary that the adjoining girls hostel sharing a common wall might collapse if the rubble was cleared too fast.

When the Municipal Corporation arrived two days later, it went door to door asking how many people lived in each room and whether the floor was authorised, while workers tossed air conditioners and almirahs off rooftops. That is how Delhi demolishes: not with engineering, but with spectacle.

We call these events accidents, order magisterial probes, file FIRs for culpable homicide not amounting to murder, suspend a junior engineer or two, announce compensation and the forget everything until the next fire. But these are not accidents. They are the logical end of a housing market in which illegality has been normalised, and safety has never been recognised as a right.

For a decade, Delhi’s idea of a "smart city" has been closely associated with command centres, facial recognition cameras and app-based complaints. Yet, none of this technology can keep a roof from falling or a corridor from filling with smoke. The real measure of a smart city is not how quickly it can detect and report a disaster but how effectively it can prevent one. That will not come from another dashboard, but only when safe housing is treated as a justiciable right.

Advertisement

Who lives in these buildings? Not those who write master plans. The dead in Malviya Nagar were budget travellers, foreign students and migrant workers who could afford nothing better. The dead in Satya Niketan were 19-21-year-olds, drawn to Delhi because their home towns lacked a university of similar standing. They pay Rs 12-20,000 for a shared bed, do not own the house, do not vote in that ward, and cannot ask for a safety certificate without risking eviction the next morning. Precarity is the business model, and because these tenants are transient, the city feels no accountability towards them. The Satya Niketan lane emptied out after the collapse; it will fill again within weeks, because Delhi University still has more applicants than hostel seats, and the city still has no regulated rental housing market.

Article 21 has long been read to mean that the right to life includes the right to a safe, dignified environment. Yet, Delhi, with its large and largely unregulated market for paying-guest accommodation, has no PG Regulation Act. Trade licences, fire NOCs, building sanctions and electricity connections operate in isolation. The Fire department, which handled over 17,000 calls in 2025 and recorded 45 deaths in the first five months of this year alone, cannot inspect every building that stands. The Municipal Corporation, both regulator and rent-seeker, has every incentive not to look too closely.

Advertisement

A law that transforms this constitutional right into a lived one must try doing three things. Firstly, to make a building’s history available to the public at large. Every building used for residential or paying-guest accommodation should carry a QR-coded occupancy passport. The passport should disclose the sanctioned and actual number of floors, sanctioned and connected electrical load, date of last structural audit, fire NOC status. This information should be displayed at the entrance and made available through a public portal. No passport means no commercial power tariff, no trade licence, no listing on aggregators. Liability must extend beyond the title-holder to the leaseholder-operator, and whoever carried out the modifications, and certification, as Mumbai adopted after the 2017 Kamala Mills fire.

Second, the law must be climate-smart for the Delhi that exists today, not the one on paper. Both tragedies were climate-amplified. The collapse followed waterlogging after heavy rain, a pattern set to worsen. Fire deaths peak during the hotter months, when air-conditioner loads strain ageing wiring. Habitable basements should be banned in flood-prone, high water-table zones. Buildings with more than ten air-conditioners should need a heat-load audit and fire-retardant wiring, since electrical faults cause roughly 60-70 per cent of Delhi's fires. Where building codes require a second staircase, it must be treated as a climate exit, not a luxury. For existing buildings that lack one, governments should support retrofitting through targeted rebates and compliance incentives.

Advertisement

Third, the law must protect the occupant, not merely the structure. Delhi should create a public registry of PGs, hostels and budget hotels with minimum standards for ventilation, floor area, evacuation routes and functioning smoke alarms. Every property should display a visible A-to-D safety rating on every door and listing platforms, much like food hygiene ratings. Tenants who report violations should receive whistleblower protection. A city-level relocation fund, financed by penalties, that can move residents of dangerous buildings to safety within forty-eight hours.

Advertisement

Delhi does not lack laws on construction and maintenance. What it surely lacks is the will to make the building more powerful than the landlord. The situation post-disaster is remarkably familiar, we throw refrigerators off rooftops, send in bulldozers, and announce ex-gratia payments. What we do not fix is the ledger that let six sanctioned rooms become twenty-five occupied ones.

It isn’t usual in any city anywhere in the world to watch its infrastructure crumble and residents entrapped, while debating the onus on television. A resilient city is one where an aspirant who comes to study can safely assume that his ceiling will stay up and his exit will stay open. But until that assumption is written into law, Delhi is not building smart cities. What it is building is taller and denser traps and calling the bodies in the rubble, ‘fate’.

Najeed Naved Siddiqui teaches at Manipal Law School, Bangalore. Nabeela Siddiqui teaches at Vinayaka Mission’s Law School, Chennai.

This article went live on October sixth, two thousand twenty six, at twenty minutes past two in the afternoon.

The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.

Advertisement
Advertisement
tlbr_img1 Series tlbr_img2 Columns tlbr_img3 Multimedia